Madison Square Garden has barred John Scola, the lawyer of a New York police officer suing the venue over injuries sustained while working security at an MSG boxing match, continuing a controversy over the arena's strict control of legal disputes.
- MSG revokes lawyer John Scola's venue access amid legal dispute.
- NYPD officer injured during boxing match security details MSG in lawsuit.
- Concerns mount over MSG's surveillance practices and police relations.
What happened
John Scola, a prominent attorney representing New York police officers, was banned from Madison Square Garden and related venues after filing a lawsuit over injuries sustained by an NYPD officer during a boxing event in February 2025. The officer, John Przybyszewski, alleges he was severely injured in a chaotic ringside incident involving rapper Lil Tjay and his entourage, while working as security through the city’s paid detail program.
Following the lawsuit, MSG sent Scola a letter revoking all his tickets to their venues. This ban continues a long-standing MSG policy under owner James Dolan, who has historically excluded legal representatives involved in disputes with the Garden, enforced using advanced facial recognition technology.
Why it matters
The ban sheds light on rising tensions between Madison Square Garden and New York City’s public servants. Despite employing off-duty NYPD officers for crowd control, MSG’s security tactics and surveillance measures have been increasingly controversial, particularly regarding their unsanctioned use of facial recognition, which has raised privacy concerns among city officials and legal advocates.
New York’s attorney general has publicly criticized MSG’s surveillance systems, emphasizing the importance of protecting citizens' rights at public events. The incident also raises questions about MSG’s accountability in ensuring the safety of off-duty officers it hires, especially given allegations of understaffing that may have contributed to the injury.
What to watch next
The ongoing lawsuit and MSG’s legal and operational response are key developments to follow. John Przybyszewski, the injured officer, has expressed a desire to return to similar security work, possibly even at MSG, despite the legal clash, highlighting complex relationships between the city’s police and the venue’s management.
Further scrutiny from city officials, including investigations into MSG’s surveillance policies and security practices, is anticipated. The case could have broader implications for how major venues balance security measures with civil liberties and labor relations with public safety personnel.