The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in Panchkula has directed Reliance Retail to pay Rs 7,500 after ruling that JioMart’s practice of crediting refunds to a reward wallet instead of the original payment method constitutes a dark pattern and violates consumer rights.

  • JioMart credited part of refund to reward wallet without customer consent.
  • Consumer panel calls this a deceptive dark pattern under CCPA guidelines.
  • Reliance Retail ordered to pay Rs 7,500 and comply within 45 days.

What happened

In a recent order dated October 28, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission in Panchkula found Reliance Retail Limited and Reliance Smart Superstore guilty of unfair trade practices for diverting a portion of a customer refund to a rewards wallet rather than the original payment method. The customer had been promised a full refund to her original payment source but received Re 1 in wallet credit against the refund.

Despite several opportunities, the companies did not file a written defense leading the commission to strike off their defense in June. The commission ordered Reliance Retail to pay Rs 7,500 as compensation and emphasized that consumers cannot be compelled to accept wallet credits instead of cash refunds.

Why it matters

This case highlights growing concerns around 'dark patterns' in e-commerce, where platforms try to nudge consumers towards non-cash wallet credits possibly encouraging further spending on their platforms. The commission referenced the Central Consumer Protection Authority’s 2023 guidelines on preventing dark patterns, underscoring regulatory efforts to curb deceptive refund practices.

The ruling is significant because the Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules, 2020 require refunds to be issued promptly but do not specify the refund mode. The commission’s pushback on wallet credit without consent sets a precedent reaffirming consumer choice and transparency in refund methods.

What to watch next

With the Central Consumer Protection Authority actively enforcing dark pattern regulations, other Indian e-commerce platforms may face increased scrutiny over their refund and wallet credit policies. Earlier actions include the CCPA’s directive to Ola in 2024 requiring customers to choose between bank refunds and coupons, signaling a broader regulatory clampdown.

Market participants should monitor compliance updates and potential penalties as the regulator continues to target unfair trade practices. Consumers may also become more aware of their rights regarding refunds, potentially driving demand for clearer policies and better platform accountability.

Source assisted: This briefing began from a discovered source item from MediaNama. Open the original source.
How SignalDesk reports: feeds and outside sources are used for discovery. Public briefings are edited to add context, buyer relevance and attribution before they are published. Read the standards

Related briefings