The Federal Communications Commission has ordered California to stop enforcing its long-standing Carrier of Last Resort rules on AT&T, enabling the company to phase out basic copper phone service and transition customers to wireless alternatives by mid-2027.
- FCC grants AT&T's request to preempt California's phone service rules
- California mandates require wireless alternatives to meet basic service standards
- FCC Democrat dissent highlights the importance of state consumer protections
What happened
This ruling aligns with actions by the Trump administration aimed at limiting state-level telecom regulations perceived as obstacles to modernization. Similar relief from COLR duties has been granted to AT&T in 20 out of its 21 wireline states. California remains the sole holdout, asserting that any wireless replacement must meet established state consumer protections, such as flat-rate pricing and discounted options for low-income users.
Why it matters
The dispute highlights a fundamental clash between state authority and federal regulatory power in telecom policy. California argues its rules reflect consumer needs and protections developed over decades, including accommodations for vulnerable populations like those who are deaf or low-income. The FCC and AT&T counter that legacy copper lines are obsolete in a competitive broadband and wireless environment, and that wireless alternatives are a sufficient replacement.
FCC Chairman Brendan Carr described California’s COLR framework as outdated for today’s technology landscape, emphasizing the need for modernization and a uniform federal approach. Meanwhile, FCC Commissioner Anna Gomez dissented, warning that state commissions serve as vital guardians for local consumers, and that wholesale preemption risks undermining ongoing state regulatory processes. The outcome of this fight could set precedent for how states can regulate legacy telecom services amid evolving technologies.
What to watch next
California is expected to challenge the FCC’s order in court, continuing its effort to preserve consumer protections and oversight of telecom service providers. The California Public Utilities Commission is also actively reviewing how to update its COLR rules to incorporate wireless service replacements adequately while maintaining service standards.
AT&T has stated it will not discontinue service before the June 1, 2027 deadline, allowing time for regulatory and legal developments. Stakeholders will monitor how courts interpret federal preemption over state telecom policy and whether additional safeguards for vulnerable consumers are adopted in this transition away from traditional landline phone service.