X has informed the Delhi High Court that takedown notices claiming to be from Delhi Police against the Internet Freedom Foundation and Software Freedom Law Center were fabricated. An internal inquiry confirmed the notices were fake, and X has filed a complaint with law enforcement.
- X found takedown notices claiming to be from Delhi Police were fake.
- Notices sought removal of posts by Internet Freedom Foundation and SFLC.in alleging defamation.
- Delhi High Court recorded X’s disclosure and disposed of related petitions.
What happened
X disclosed to the Delhi High Court that two takedown requests sent in the name of the Delhi Police Special Commissioner of Police were fraudulent. These notices sought the removal of posts by Internet Freedom Foundation (IFF) and Software Freedom Law Center (SFLC.in) alleging defamatory content against the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS).
An internal investigation by X confirmed an imposter submitted the takedown requests. Consequently, X filed a complaint with law enforcement authorities. The court took note of X’s statement and dismissed the petitions filed by the organizations, though it allowed them to approach the court again if X acts against their accounts in the future.
Why it matters
This incident highlights challenges around verifying government-issued content takedown requests and underscores risks of impersonation in the content moderation ecosystem. Transparency reports and legal notices played a key role in scrutinizing the authenticity of these requests.
The case occurs amid broader tensions in India over platform responsibilities and limitations on intermediary liability. Government agencies have been active in issuing content removal demands, raising concerns about free speech protections and the potential for misuse or mistaken requests.
What to watch next
Observers will monitor if platforms like X enhance verification protocols for takedown notices to prevent impersonation and wrongful removals. The Delhi Police and other authorities may also respond to the complaint about the fake notices and clarify their official procedures.
Developments regarding India’s Information Technology laws, including considerations to withdraw safe harbour protections for intermediaries, will be crucial. This could substantially affect how platforms handle government takedown demands and the balance between lawful content regulation and freedom of expression.